By
Dawn Lille
Dance
On Camera 2008, the 36th
annual festival and symposium sponsored by Dance Film Association
and one of the most important of its kind in this country, could be
seen all over town during the first two weeks of January, in addition
to the Walter Reade Theater at Lincoln Center. The varied international
offerings allowed one to learn, laugh, empathize, cry, realize how
far the combination of film and dance has to come and wonder where
it might go. Experiments
in still and moving photography date back to 1867 and Edweard Muybridge’s
serial photographs of racehorses. By 1889 Thomas Edison and his colleagues
had invented the Kinetograph, which allowed rolls of film to be viewed
successively through a Kinetescope, producing what seemed to be a
moving image. In 1895 the Lumiere brothers, in France, created what
developed into the Vitascope machine, which first showed moving pictures
in New York in 1896. The first luxurious “movie house” was built in
Pittsburgh in 1905 The
interest in moving objects during these early developments was universal
and Edison and others filmed many dancers and music hall performers,
leaving historians with a source of what these tightrope walkers in
pointe shoes looked like. Additionally, early films exist of Anna
Pavlova, about 30 seconds of Isadora Duncan (filmed by a guest behind
a tree at a garden party), of Loie Fuller and numerous dance sequences,
including a lengthy one in D.W. Griffith’s Intolerance, as
well as others that tended to satirize many dance forms. There were
also the remarkable movement sequences of Charlie Chaplin and Buster
Keaton. But
it was the 1930’s, after the debut of the “talkies,” that saw a proliferation
of dance in film. It was via this that millions of people across the
United States not only sought relief from the anxieties of the depression,
but were exposed to dance, many for the first time. The sequences
created by Busby Berkeley and shot from above, the subtle effects
of the team of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, the extraordinary performances
of the Nicholas Brothers and other tap and jazz performers were only
a few of the many dance talents that filled movie theaters.
One
could also see classical ballet performed by Mia Slavenska and Vera
Zorina in one of the four films George Balanchine choreographed in
Hollywood, for which the musical was a mainstay. The Red Shoes, probably the most popular ballet film of all times, appeared in 1948
and was followed by others containing every possible genre of dance.
Films and videos from all over the world continued to proliferate
during the last quarter off the 20th century and today
one can go to Youtube and see dance that was performed 24 hours earlier. Film
as an art form, and the combination of dance and film as still another
creative art, have changed radically since Edison’s day. Realizing
that film can change or distort the viewer’s perception of movement
and its elements of composition and rhythm, directors and choreographers
have developed different methods of collaboration, often incorporating
the latest technology. The filming of an already choreographed work is a form that was adopted by folklorists, anthropologists and choreographers wishing a record of a particular dance. Creating a dance work specifically for film is an entirely different genre. It is this meshing of dance and other media arts, always in flux, that can continue to alter time and space and the concept of what dance is. The films shown in January ranged from a restored one of a 1975 performance of Spartacus, a Soviet era work danced by the Bolshoi Ballet, to documentaries about well known dancers, to short humorous antics and flights of the imagination, to works that are the result of the artistic vision of both the choreographer and the filmmaker. In
connection with the latter, dancer/choreographer Austin McCormick
was the winner of the first DFA Young Choreographers Initiative, created
to encourage new dance makers to combine their talents with those
of a filmmaker, in this case Philip Buiser. The result was Folies
d’Espagne a seven-minute, rich, sensual and beautifully costumed
work inspired by Baroque dance. McCormick, who graduated from Juilliard
in ‘06, also gave a surprise live performance with his group,
Company XIV, that mixed dance and video. The
co-winners of the festival’s first prize were Water Flowing Together,
a full length portrait of the New York City ballet dancer Jock Soto
by Gwendolyn Cates, and the short Flying by Phil Hardy, Rosanne
Chamecki and Andrea Lerner, that used film technology to show its
calmly jubilant performers seeming to fly through space. The Soto
film, which contains some exciting dance sequences, had its first
showing during the festival at the New York State Theater before an
audience of two thousand. Its portrayal pf this very special dancer
was without pretense and flowed well.
Two
films on the same program about Russian ballerinas, Felia Doubrovska
Remembered by Virginia Brooks, and Sleeping Ballerina by
Ludovic Kennedy, revealed Doubrovska and Olga Spessivtzeva. Classmates
at the ballet school of the Maryinsky Theater in St. Petersburg, both
had danced with the Diaghilev Ballets Russes and both eventually came
to America. Ironically, Doubrovska, who had taught many in the audience,
was one of a small group who worked to get Spessivtzeva moved out
of a mental institution and into lodgings at the Tolstoy Foundation. Another
documentary, Pina Bausch, by Anne Linsel, shows the influential
German choreographer in an open, almost relaxed mood as she talks
about the path she felt she had to follow and why. One
program, entitled “The Choreographic Moves of Jacques Tati,” showed
a restored full color version of the classic Jour de Fete by
this French actor of humor and pathos as he moved on his bicycle through
rural France. Among
the “New Ideas and Shorts” category was Car-Men, a takeoff
on the Bizet opera by Boris Pavel Conem and the choreographer Jiri
Kylian. This is a slapstick comedy performed by four dancers who alternate
between speeding in cars, stillness and clambering around a huge scrap
car. Someone was heard to ask, “But is it dance?” but no one answered! On
the final day of the festival I caught up with Underground dance
masters: Final History of a Forgotten Era. Made by Thomas Guzman
-Sanchez, this is a history of Boogaloo, Locking, Popping, Roboting,
Rocking and B-Boying, all urban dance forms closely connected to music
that sprang up in different places, mostly in California. What developed
in the Bronx had a Latino component. In the audience were young students
from the Hip Hop Conservatory in the Bronx. One
session, offered to all and free of charge, was on “Fair Use” and
was co-sponsored by the Dance Heritage Coalition. Led by Peter Jaszi,
Professor of Law at American University and director of the Program
on Intellectual Property and the Public Interest, it considered the
Fair Use Doctrine that was written into the Copyright Act of 1976.
Explained simply, this is the right of scholars and others to use
copyrighted material in cases where cultural benefits outweigh economic
costs or profits. Since the application of this idea can be vague,
documentary filmmakers got together and decided on the criteria to
be followed in their discipline. This includes when the creator of
a new piece may use or quote an already copyrighted section of material.
The issue is one that, ultimately, concerns all contemporary artists. Dance
Films Association was founded in 1956 by Susan Braun as a result of
her frustration at not being able to locate certain films. Now directed
by Deidre Towers, it fosters collaboration, tours films internationally
and has inspired similar organizations worldwide. The festival was
co-sponsored by the Film Society of Lincoln Center |